• Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Login
VIP Articles
Subscribe
Defensionem - The WarBible

No products in the cart.

  • Books
  • Short Posts
  • VIP
  • Aviation
  • Land
  • History
  • Syrian Conflict Watch
  • Sea
  • Countries
    • China
    • India
    • Middle East
    • Russia
    • South America
    • Syrian Conflict
    • United States of America (USA)
    • United Kingdom (UK)
  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Books
  • Short Posts
  • VIP
  • Aviation
  • Land
  • History
  • Syrian Conflict Watch
  • Sea
  • Countries
    • China
    • India
    • Middle East
    • Russia
    • South America
    • Syrian Conflict
    • United States of America (USA)
    • United Kingdom (UK)
  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
Defensionem
Login
Home Countries

Tanks. West vs East. Which one is the best? The American Abrams, German Leopards, British Challengers versus different Russian “T series”

by Renaud Mayers
1 year ago
in Countries
Reading Time: 5min read
0

Tanks… West vs East.

The internet is full of comparisons between Western and Russian tanks. There is no end to the “which is best” video list on Youtube, pitting American M1 Abrams, German Leopards, and the British Challengers versus the different Russian “T series”.

Pictured is the UK Main Battle Tank, Challenger 2 Theatre Entry Standard (CR2 TES) fitted with a Mobile Camouflage System (MCS), also known as Megatron. © Crown Copyright 2014 Photographer: Harland Quarrington Image

The confrontation usually continues in the comment sections of those videos where armies of obnoxious fanboys jump at each other’s throat.

So many different factors are at play when one has to decide which tank is “best”… As we have all seen in Syria, Yemen and in Iraq, a bad crew inside a good tank does not achieve much… Strategy, tactics, crew training, the logistic train supporting the tanks off the battlefield and the infantry supporting the tank on the battlefield are all extremely important and can override any flaws or outstanding features on any tank.

For a long time, one of the downside of using a Russian tank was its ammunition size. The Russian autoloaders are usually using 2 pieces ammunition, restricting the length of the penetrator on sabot rounds, and therefore restricting the penetration abilities of said ammunition.

This seems to come at an end as the upcoming T-14 Armata uses a new gun/autoloader combo that enables it to fire the “Vacuum” family of APFSDS rounds that closes the East-West gap in penetrator length.

Protection was earlier an advantage of Soviet models and their composite armour. The advantage then swung toward Western models with the Abrams used as an example: Its Chobham armour with depleted Uranium plates providing this tank with an exceptional level of crew protection. The Uranium plates are supposed to be so dense, they can shatter a sabot/penetrator on impact. Again, the Russians seem to have closed the gap as shown in Syria with T-90A and even older but modernised T-62M shrugging off direct hits from ATGM missiles. In the first 18 months of continuous service with the Syrian army, only 2 T-90A were lost. This included one abandoned by its crew and subsequently recovered by rebel militias. The Russians drew lessons from that conflict to come up with an improved and better-protected variant of the T-72B3 (T-72B3 Obr. 2016) and did the same for the T-90(A) with the new T-90M.

So… who holds the advantage? The answer might be found in the various sights found on modern tanks… The M1A2 SEP sports a Raytheon gunner sights that have a maximum magnification of X50. The latest Russian tanks are equipped with the Sosna-U gunner sights that have a max magnification of X12… Across the board, it seems Western tanks are fitted with better quality thermal imagery, better/more powerful sights and slightly better Fire Control Systems/computers.

What does this mean? Well, if we keep the M1A2 as a comparison, say, with a T-90SM, it seems the crew of the Abrams would be able to detect, identify and accurately engage a T-90SM while on the move at longer range while the crew in the T-90SM might not detect the Abrams on time and might find it difficult to engage it on the move at ranges exceeding 2 to 3 kilometers.

So, which one is the best? Well… Usually, the best tank is the one with the best crew fighting for the side with the best strategy and tactics, with the best logistic train at the back, the best supporting infantry at the front and air support above the battlefield. See what we did, here ?!

ShareTweetSend

Renaud Mayers

Currently working on behalf of the Belgian Ministry of Defence, thanks to my knowledge in WWII and other areas. Working in two WWII era fortresses still belonging to the Army.

Related Posts

Budget: How much Russia really spends on Defence
Russia

Budget: How much Russia really spends on Defence

by Renaud Mayers
January 29, 2021
0
War Game: When generals play "Risk"
Featured

War Game: When generals play “Risk”

by Renaud Mayers
January 27, 2021
0
Artillery strike on Zelenopillya: Carnage on the Ukrainian plains.
Russia

Artillery strike on Zelenopillya: Carnage on the Ukrainian plains.

by Renaud Mayers
January 20, 2021
0
Admiral Kuznetsov and beyond: Russia's LHDs
Russia

Admiral Kuznetsov and beyond: Russia’s LHDs

by Renaud Mayers
January 17, 2021
0
  • Books
  • Aviation
  • Land
  • Countries
  • Short Posts
  • Syrian Conflict Watch
  • Libyan Conflict Watch
  • Subscription Plans
  • Our Authors
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Write For Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
Contact Us: [email protected]

© 2020 Defensionem - The WarBible - a reliable source of information about conflicts & weapon systems from the world over.

No Result
View All Result
  • Aviation
  • Land
  • Syrian Conflict Watch
  • Sea
  • History
  • Countries
    • Germany
    • Middle East
    • United Kingdom (UK)
    • India
    • China
    • South America
    • Featured
    • Russia
    • United States of America (USA)
    • Syria
  • Libyan Conflict Watch
  • Short Posts
  • Subscription Plans
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy

© 2020 Defensionem - The WarBible - a reliable source of information about conflicts & weapon systems from the world over.

Log In ×
Forgot your Password?
Login With OTP
Resend OTP(00:30)
Don't have an account?
Signup
Resend OTP(00:30)
Back to login

Resend OTP (00:30)
Back to login
  • (+93) Afghanistan
  • (+355) Albania
  • (+213) Algeria
  • (+1) American Samoa
  • (+376) Andorra
  • (+244) Angola
  • (+1) Anguilla
  • (+1) Antigua
  • (+54) Argentina
  • (+374) Armenia
  • (+297) Aruba
  • (+61) Australia
  • (+43) Austria
  • (+994) Azerbaijan
  • (+973) Bahrain
  • (+880) Bangladesh
  • (+1) Barbados
  • (+375) Belarus
  • (+32) Belgium
  • (+501) Belize
  • (+229) Benin
  • (+1) Bermuda
  • (+975) Bhutan
  • (+591) Bolivia
  • (+599) Bonaire, Sint Eustatius and Saba
  • (+387) Bosnia and Herzegovina
  • (+267) Botswana
  • (+55) Brazil
  • (+246) British Indian Ocean Territory
  • (+1) British Virgin Islands
  • (+673) Brunei
  • (+359) Bulgaria
  • (+226) Burkina Faso
  • (+257) Burundi
  • (+855) Cambodia
  • (+237) Cameroon
  • (+1) Canada
  • (+238) Cape Verde
  • (+1) Cayman Islands
  • (+236) Central African Republic
  • (+235) Chad
  • (+56) Chile
  • (+86) China
  • (+57) Colombia
  • (+269) Comoros
  • (+682) Cook Islands
  • (+225) Côte d'Ivoire
  • (+506) Costa Rica
  • (+385) Croatia
  • (+53) Cuba
  • (+599) Curaçao
  • (+357) Cyprus
  • (+420) Czech Republic
  • (+243) Democratic Republic of the Congo
  • (+45) Denmark
  • (+253) Djibouti
  • (+1) Dominica
  • (+1) Dominican Republic
  • (+593) Ecuador
  • (+20) Egypt
  • (+503) El Salvador
  • (+240) Equatorial Guinea
  • (+291) Eritrea
  • (+372) Estonia
  • (+251) Ethiopia
  • (+500) Falkland Islands
  • (+298) Faroe Islands
  • (+691) Federated States of Micronesia
  • (+679) Fiji
  • (+358) Finland
  • (+33) France
  • (+594) French Guiana
  • (+689) French Polynesia
  • (+241) Gabon
  • (+995) Georgia
  • (+49) Germany
  • (+233) Ghana
  • (+350) Gibraltar
  • (+30) Greece
  • (+299) Greenland
  • (+1) Grenada
  • (+590) Guadeloupe
  • (+1) Guam
  • (+502) Guatemala
  • (+44) Guernsey
  • (+224) Guinea
  • (+245) Guinea-Bissau
  • (+592) Guyana
  • (+509) Haiti
  • (+504) Honduras
  • (+852) Hong Kong
  • (+36) Hungary
  • (+354) Iceland
  • (+91) India
  • (+62) Indonesia
  • (+98) Iran
  • (+964) Iraq
  • (+353) Ireland
  • (+44) Isle Of Man
  • (+972) Israel
  • (+39) Italy
  • (+1) Jamaica
  • (+81) Japan
  • (+44) Jersey
  • (+962) Jordan
  • (+7) Kazakhstan
  • (+254) Kenya
  • (+686) Kiribati
  • (+965) Kuwait
  • (+996) Kyrgyzstan
  • (+856) Laos
  • (+371) Latvia
  • (+961) Lebanon
  • (+266) Lesotho
  • (+231) Liberia
  • (+218) Libya
  • (+423) Liechtenstein
  • (+370) Lithuania
  • (+352) Luxembourg
  • (+853) Macau
  • (+389) Macedonia
  • (+261) Madagascar
  • (+265) Malawi
  • (+60) Malaysia
  • (+960) Maldives
  • (+223) Mali
  • (+356) Malta
  • (+692) Marshall Islands
  • (+596) Martinique
  • (+222) Mauritania
  • (+230) Mauritius
  • (+262) Mayotte
  • (+52) Mexico
  • (+373) Moldova
  • (+377) Monaco
  • (+976) Mongolia
  • (+382) Montenegro
  • (+1) Montserrat
  • (+212) Morocco
  • (+258) Mozambique
  • (+95) Myanmar
  • (+264) Namibia
  • (+674) Nauru
  • (+977) Nepal
  • (+31) Netherlands
  • (+687) New Caledonia
  • (+64) New Zealand
  • (+505) Nicaragua
  • (+227) Niger
  • (+234) Nigeria
  • (+683) Niue
  • (+672) Norfolk Island
  • (+850) North Korea
  • (+1) Northern Mariana Islands
  • (+47) Norway
  • (+968) Oman
  • (+92) Pakistan
  • (+680) Palau
  • (+970) Palestine
  • (+507) Panama
  • (+675) Papua New Guinea
  • (+595) Paraguay
  • (+51) Peru
  • (+63) Philippines
  • (+48) Poland
  • (+351) Portugal
  • (+1) Puerto Rico
  • (+974) Qatar
  • (+242) Republic of the Congo
  • (+40) Romania
  • (+262) Runion
  • (+7) Russia
  • (+250) Rwanda
  • (+290) Saint Helena
  • (+1) Saint Kitts and Nevis
  • (+508) Saint Pierre and Miquelon
  • (+1) Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
  • (+685) Samoa
  • (+378) San Marino
  • (+239) Sao Tome and Principe
  • (+966) Saudi Arabia
  • (+221) Senegal
  • (+381) Serbia
  • (+248) Seychelles
  • (+232) Sierra Leone
  • (+65) Singapore
  • (+1) Sint Maarten
  • (+421) Slovakia
  • (+386) Slovenia
  • (+677) Solomon Islands
  • (+252) Somalia
  • (+27) South Africa
  • (+82) South Korea
  • (+211) South Sudan
  • (+34) Spain
  • (+94) Sri Lanka
  • (+1) St. Lucia
  • (+249) Sudan
  • (+597) Suriname
  • (+268) Swaziland
  • (+46) Sweden
  • (+41) Switzerland
  • (+963) Syria
  • (+886) Taiwan
  • (+992) Tajikistan
  • (+255) Tanzania
  • (+66) Thailand
  • (+1) The Bahamas
  • (+220) The Gambia
  • (+670) Timor-Leste
  • (+228) Togo
  • (+690) Tokelau
  • (+676) Tonga
  • (+1) Trinidad and Tobago
  • (+216) Tunisia
  • (+90) Turkey
  • (+993) Turkmenistan
  • (+1) Turks and Caicos Islands
  • (+688) Tuvalu
  • (+1) U.S. Virgin Islands
  • (+256) Uganda
  • (+380) Ukraine
  • (+971) United Arab Emirates
  • (+44) United Kingdom
  • (+1) United States
  • (+598) Uruguay
  • (+998) Uzbekistan
  • (+678) Vanuatu
  • (+58) Venezuela
  • (+84) Vietnam
  • (+681) Wallis and Futuna
  • (+212) Western Sahara
  • (+967) Yemen
  • (+260) Zambia
  • (+263) Zimbabwe
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?